Should I Get My Cabinets Painted or Replaced?

Home » Cabinet Cures of the Triangle Blog » Should I Get My Cabinets Painted or Replaced?

When it comes to updating your kitchen, the question of whether to paint or replace your cabinets is one that many homeowners face. On the surface, painting (also known as refinishing) offers a quick, low-cost solution, while replacing your cabinets provides a completely new look but comes with a hefty price tag. However, there’s a third option that often goes unnoticed: cabinet refacing.

Join the cabinet refacing experts from Cabinet Cures of the Triangle as we explore all three options in detail—painting, replacing, and refacing—to help you make an informed decision. Spoiler alert: refacing is not only the most cost-effective choice in the long run, but it also offers a stylish, modern update that strikes the perfect balance between affordability and transformation.

should-i-get-my-kitchen-cabinets-painted-or-replaced

Cabinet Painting (aka Refinishing)

Cabinet painting, often referred to as refinishing, involves applying a fresh coat of paint to your existing cabinet surfaces. The process typically begins with cleaning and sanding the cabinet surfaces to remove old paint or finish. Once prepped, a primer is applied, followed by one or more layers of paint to achieve the desired color and finish. While this method can offer a quick visual refresh, it doesn’t alter the underlying structure or material of the cabinets.

Pros of Cabinet Refinishing

Painting offers some advantages, particularly in terms of cost and time:

  • Cost-Effective in the Short Term: Painting is generally the least expensive option for updating cabinets.
  • Faster Process: The painting process can be completed relatively quickly, often within a few days.

Cons of Cabinet Refinishing

However, painting also has its drawbacks, primarily due to its limited impact:

  • Cosmetic Fix Only: Painting doesn’t improve the cabinet structure, only alters the appearance.
  • Limited Modernization: It doesn’t allow for significant style changes or updates.
  • Potential for Wear and Tear: Painted cabinets can chip, peel, or fade over time, requiring additional maintenance.

Cabinet Replacement

Cabinet replacement involves completely removing your existing cabinets, including the cabinet boxes, doors, and hardware, and replacing them with entirely new cabinetry. Replacement allows for a full redesign of your kitchen, offering the opportunity to change the layout, add new storage features, and select from a wide variety of materials, styles, and finishes. It’s essentially a complete overhaul of your kitchen’s cabinetry.

Advantages of Cabinet Replacement

Replacing cabinets provides the opportunity for a complete overhaul of your kitchen:

  • Complete Transformation: Offers the most significant change in appearance and functionality.
  • Customization Options: Allows for full customization with new materials, styles, and features.
  • Structural Improvements: Addresses any underlying issues with the existing cabinets.

Cabinet Replacement Drawbacks

Despite its benefits, cabinet replacement comes with significant downsides:

  • Very Expensive: The most costly option, factoring in new cabinets and installation.
  • Time-Consuming: Requires weeks of work, during which your kitchen may be unusable.
  • Potential for Overkill: May be unnecessary if your existing cabinet boxes are still in good condition.

The Hidden Gem: Cabinet Refacing

Custom cabinet refacing is an often-overlooked option that offers a perfect middle ground between cabinet painting and full replacement. With cabinet refacing, the existing cabinet boxes remain intact, but the exterior surfaces—such as the cabinet doors, drawer fronts, and hardware—are completely replaced with new, updated materials. This process gives your kitchen a brand-new look and feel without the cost or hassle of installing entirely new cabinets.

Cabinet Refacing Benefits

Cabinet refacing combines the best aspects of both cabinet painting and replacement, making it an ideal choice for many homeowners: 

  • Cost-Effective and Affordable: Refacing is significantly less expensive than full cabinet replacement, offering a fresh look without breaking the bank.
  • Quick and Efficient Process: The refacing process is much faster than replacement, usually completed in just a few days, minimizing the disruption to your home.
  • Modernizes Your Kitchen: Refacing allows for a wide variety of style options, including different finishes, colors, and hardware, enabling you to drastically update your kitchen’s appearance.
  • Environmentally Friendly: By reusing your existing cabinet boxes, refacing is a more sustainable option that reduces waste and the need for new materials.

Cabinet Refacing Challenges

While refacing is an excellent choice for most, there are a few considerations to keep in mind: 

  • Slightly Higher Cost than Painting: While more affordable than replacement, refacing is generally more expensive than simply painting your cabinets.
  • Limited Structural Changes: Refacing won’t allow you to change the layout of your kitchen or add new cabinet configurations, as the existing cabinet boxes remain in place

Why Cabinet Refacing is the Superior Choice for NC Homeowners

Cabinet refacing offers an exceptional balance of cost, convenience, and transformation. It provides a modern, updated look that rivals full cabinet replacement, without the hefty price tag or extended timeline. 

For homeowners looking to refresh their kitchen, refacing stands out as the superior option, delivering long-term value, enhanced aesthetics, and improved functionality—all without the need for a complete cabinet overhaul. 

With cabinet refacing, homeowners can enjoy a number of different refreshed renovations to their kitchen, including: 

If you’re considering a kitchen renovation, don’t settle for the limitations of cabinet painting or the expense of cabinet replacement. Cabinet refacing offers the perfect solution, allowing you to enjoy a beautifully updated kitchen that feels brand new, at a fraction of the cost. With Cabinet Cures, you can achieve the kitchen of your dreams, combining style, durability, and affordability in one seamless process.

Connect With Raleigh’s #1 Cabinet Refacing Experts

​​Ready to transform your kitchen with a fresh, modern look? Contact our Raleigh cabinet refacing experts today.

At Cabinet Cures of the Triangle, we specialize in giving your cabinets a stunning update at a fraction of the cost of replacement. Serving the greater Triangle area in North Carolina, including Raleigh, Durham, and Chapel Hill, our team is here to help you achieve the kitchen of your dreams. 

Reach out now by calling us at  919–809–6161 or filling out the form below to schedule a consultation and discover the benefits of cabinet refacing for your home!

Related Posts